Is the Answer Hidden in Your Files—How to Re-Examine Your Research Clues

As genealogists, we spend countless hours tracking down documents, searching databases, and digging through archives to uncover the answers to our toughest research questions. But what if I told you that the answer you’ve been looking for might already be in your files—hidden in plain sight?

It happens more often than you’d think. We get so focused on gathering new information that we sometimes overlook the details we’ve already collected. Maybe you recorded a fact years ago that didn’t seem important at the time, or perhaps you skimmed past a crucial name in an old census record because you weren’t looking for it back then. Our brains are wired to filter out what we don’t expect to see, which means that even the most careful researcher can miss something essential.

If you’ve hit a brick wall in your research, it’s time to take a fresh look at what you already have. You may be surprised at what you find when you slow down and examine your files with a new perspective.

Why We Overlook Important Information

There are several reasons why we miss key details in our own research:

Too Much Information, Too Little Organization

Over time, genealogy research can pile up—stacks of documents, notebooks filled with notes, digital files scattered across different folders. When your research isn’t organized, it’s easy for a critical clue to get buried under a mountain of paper or lost in an unsearchable file name.

Our Brains Skim Over Familiar Information

Once we’ve looked at a document multiple times, our brains tend to skim over it instead of reading it carefully. If you weren’t looking for a particular detail when you first reviewed a document, you may have mentally filtered it out. Now that your research focus has changed, that overlooked piece of information could be the key to your answer.

We Focus on What We Expect to Find

If you’re searching for a birth record, you might overlook a land deed that proves a family relationship. If you’re focused on census records, you might not pay close attention to a court case mentioned in a newspaper clipping. Our expectations shape what we see, which means we can miss unexpected clues.

Distractions and Rushed Research Sessions

Let’s be honest—sometimes we rush through our research sessions. Whether we’re short on time or just excited to move forward, we don’t always give every document the deep attention it deserves. Small details get lost in the shuffle, and we move on without realizing what we’ve missed.

The Solution: A Slow, Methodical Review

The best way to find hidden clues in your own research is to go through it line by line, word by word, document by document—without distractions. Here’s how to do it effectively:

1. Gather All Your Research in One Place

Before you start reviewing, take inventory of what you have. Having everything in one place allows you to methodically go through each piece without missing anything.This includes:

• Printed documents and paper files

• Digital files on your computer or genealogy software

• Notes from past research sessions

• Emails or messages from other researchers

• Photos, letters, and heirlooms with handwritten notes

  
  

2. Eliminate Distractions

Set aside dedicated time to focus solely on this task. Turn off your phone notifications, close unnecessary browser tabs, and find a quiet place where you won’t be interrupted. The goal is to give each document your full attention.

Also, do not work any further once you realize you are tired and not able to concentrate. We miss answers when we are unable to focus. By stepping away just as we get fatigued, we can make more progress and do better work in the long run.

3. Read Every Document Word by Word

Even if you think you’ve already read a document thoroughly, approach it as if you’re seeing it for the first time. Read slowly and deliberately. Consider transcribing them. The process of writing out a document word for word forces you to slow down and absorb every detail. Look for:

• Names you previously ignored

• Addresses, occupations, and household members you didn’t pay attention to

• Marginal notes, signatures, and unusual markings

• Unexpected connections between people and places

4. Take Notes as You Go

As you re-examine each document, keep a notebook or digital file open to jot down anything new that stands out. Pay attention to:

• Names that match other records in your research

• Dates that create a timeline you hadn’t noticed before

• Discrepancies or conflicting information that need further investigation

• Mentions of locations that could lead to new sources

  
  

5. Compare Documents Side by Side

Sometimes, the answer isn’t in a single record but in the connections between multiple sources. This side-by-side analysis can reveal overlooked connections that weren’t obvious when each document was viewed in isolation. Lay documents out side by side and compare:

• Do the names and dates match across different records?

• Are there patterns in locations or occupations?

• Do any new relationships emerge when you look at documents together?

6. Ask Yourself New Questions

Reframing the way you look at your documents can open up new avenues for discovery. Now that you’re looking at your records with fresh eyes, take a step back and ask yourself:

• What assumptions did I make when I first reviewed this document?

• Is there a piece of information that I dismissed as unimportant?

• Could this record be connected to another ancestor I wasn’t researching at the time?

• Have I double-checked every source citation and location detail?

7. Organize and Document Your Findings

Once you’ve completed your review, take the time to organize your research properly. The more organized your research is, the less likely important details will get lost again in the future. This might mean:

• Creating a research log to track what you’ve found

• Renaming and filing digital documents in a logical system

• Writing a research summary that outlines what you’ve discovered

• Updating family trees and notes with new details

A Real-Life Example

A researcher/friend of mine was searching for the parents of her great-great-grandmother, but every avenue led to a dead end. After months of frustration, she decided to go back through every record she had collected—word by word. That’s when she noticed something she had overlooked before: on an old tax record, there was a note next to a man with the same last name as her ancestor. The note read, “Paid by daughter M. Smith.” She had seen the record before but never thought to connect it to her great-great-grandmother. That small detail was the key to identifying her ancestor’s parents.

In another real-life event, a (really advanced, amazing) colleague was stumped - she could not identify a man's wife. She'd researched and researched. She was carrying the man's file to her desk one day and dropped it. Papers went everywhere. She decided to just take the time to reorganize it. And... in the copies of his probate was a bill for the coffin of his widow - with her name on it! She had seen this many times before but because she was working on other questions at those times, she overlooked the significance. Once her mind was in a habit to overlook it, she missed the answer - and it was right there the whole time.

If you’re feeling stuck in your genealogy research, take a step back from searching for new information and re-examine what you’ve already collected. The answers to your toughest questions may be hidden in the notes, files, and documents you’ve had all along.

By slowing down, removing distractions, and analyzing every word with fresh eyes, you’ll give yourself the best chance of uncovering those hidden details that could break through your brick wall.

So, grab your files, clear your schedule, and start digging—you may already have the answer you’ve been searching for.

Want a FREE presentation for your genealogy society? or a private webinar for a group of genealogy friends? We can do that! We will even set the Zoom session up for you. Check out the presentation page here. It's EASY!

---

Need help organizing a genealogy project? Try the proprietary Brick Wall Buster Cards kit today! This program will change the way you research and give you the genealogy answers you want!